I would say Collins was the bigger tragedy. Say what you will about which was the more talented in college, but when they reached the pros, Collins was able to make the roster, and showed some promise at the NFL level before screwing up his last opportunity. http://www.miamidolphins.com/newsite/history/pastseasonstatistics/1999.asp#1999 Clarett, when given one more chance, could not even earn himself a single official carry in the NFL. http://www.denverbroncos.com/page.php?id=1728
I know there was no Rivals or Scout when Collins was recruited, but were there any personality red-flags about him?
There were only 2 REPORTED Breaking and Entering charges. The rumors were that it happened a lot more than twice. But I agree with what VABuckeye said. They both had everything given to them on a silver platter because of their great talent and they decided to waste it all on stupid stunts.
The sky was really the limit, and I don't think anyone will say that just for sentimental reasons, Cecil was the real deal, very sad.
I believe he had gotten in trouble in Leesville while he was still in HS. That's why DiNardo was so quick with the axe when he got in trouble at LSU.
I refuse to defend Maurice Clarett any more than to say there has probably never been anyone who was twice the amazing speciment of an RB as him, his combine performance (two years after playing a game) notwithstanding. Neither story was tragic. The drunk driver that killed 5 people in Toledo the other night was tragic, two jackass football players who wasted incredible amounts of talent is not.
