Minimum 140 Starts 1. Brees................ 96.1 2. Manning.......... 95.7 2. Young.............. 95.7 4. Brady............... 95.5 5. Rivers............... 95.0 6. Warner............. 94.5 7. Roethlisberger 93.8 8. Montana.......... 92.8 Updated after 2015 season.
Joe Montana, the 7th best QB,.. just slightly better than Roethlisberger, but not nearly as good as Phillip Rivers
Throwing to the greatest WR of all time, some say the greatest player of all time, with another great WR, John Taylor, on the other side. All-Pro OL with great backups, Eddie D wasn't afraid to spend daddy's $$$. Roger Craig as a running back. With one of the greatest offensively minded (and innovative) head coaches of all time. Montana was a great QB, for sure, but he had a GREAT surrounding cast.
an update to this 1. Brees........ 96.1 ...Manning.... 96.1 3. Brady........ 95.7 ...Young.........95.7 5. Rivers........95.3
He is probably the best QB of all time, but I hate him for all the years he tortured the Saints in the old NFC West. So many times we pulled defeat from the jaws of victory with his penchant for the dramatic 4th Q comeback. If it wasn't for that team in that era, I believe the Saints, with the dominant defense that they had, would have won at least one Super Bowl.