Both players have a redshirt to give. McGill may start this year if he can beat out Will Arnold, Herman Johnson, and others. Obviously, if he goes into the season as a starting guard, he should not redshirt. I am asking if he should consider redshirting if he goes into the season as a reserve. He is a senior. If he redshirts, he would have a much better chance to start in 2006, because we lose Whitworth, Niswanger, and Livings. From LSU's perspective, he would help the OL transition into 2006 after losing those three senior starters. I think Spadoni should consider redshirting. He is buried on the depth chart behind Broussard, Addai, Vincent, and Carey. Even Hester was ahead of him last year. Next year, Broussard or Vincent may leave early if one is the starter and has a big year on a top 5 team. Addai and Carey are definitely gone. Spadoni might be #2 on the depth chart going into 2006. He has good size and talent. Coaches like to have an experienced player like Spadoni. Thoughts?