Who is the best high school player you have ever seen live? Marcus Dupree, Philadelphia, MS. and then Oklahoma and New Orleans Breakers (USFL) He was unstopable in HS. A man among boys. Which player would you have most wanted to see in high school? Herschel Walker. Can you imagine him playing HS ball. I bet there are a lot of middle aged men talking about the night they played old Herschel and how they got to hit him.