You act like the speed increased on D, but not on O. If the triple option can't make it with today's athletes, then why has Paul Johnson been so successful with during his coaching career, so much so that Georgia Tech hired him? Why has GT (ranked #14) been so successful this year with the triple option? Why are schools with sub-par talent successful with the triple option, like Air Force (8-4) and Navy (8-5)?
Nowadays, so few teams use the triple option that nobody has any experience playing against it (I imagine the real reason the triple option died out was because it was a gimmick offense that too many teams started using, so it "saturated the market" so much that the gimmick didn't work anymore).
The reason the triple option is so successful is because it neutralizes the advantage of superior athletes, by refocussing the game on decision making and execution. When a team with BCS-conference athletes (like GT) runs the option, the triple option is even more difficult to defend.
If you want to read what a coach has to say about this, this is what Terry Bowden wrote:
There are a lot of great story lines heading into the 2008 college football season, but the best one involving X's and O's is whether Georgia Tech can be successful running a one-dimensional triple option running attack at the BCS level. New head coach Paul Johnson will implement the same offense that brought him so much success at Navy and Division I-AA Georgia Southern.
...
So, will Johnson be successful running the triple option at Georgia Tech?
Absolutely.
...
Want to know why?
First, Johnson is an outstanding head coach at any level of football. He was highly successful at, not one, but two different schools running the triple option. While at the Division I-AA level, like Jim Tressel, Johnson led his team to multiple national championships.
Second, the triple option is a tried-and-true system that has been extremely successful at the highest level of football. Head coaches and offensive and defensive systems might have changed many times over the past 40 years, but the field is still 100 yards long and 53 2/3 yards wide and you can still only use 11 people at a time to play the game.
More specifically:
• The triple option is a unique system that other teams will not see week in and week out making it much harder to prepare for.
• Johnson has run the offense almost his entire career and he will be able to make on-the-field adjustments twice as fast as the defensive coordinators he will be facing.
• He has a vast array of splits, formations and motions to alter the appearance of the exact same plays.
• Because this is a system that is based upon creating as many third-and-short yardage situations as possible, they are in their comfort zone when it comes to executing critical short yardage and goal-line plays.
• Since you win championships with defense, no offense in the country has the ability to control the clock better than the triple option. The more you control the clock with your offense, the more your defense is resting on the bench.
...
like the impact Rich Rodriguez made in the Big East and Urban Meyer in the SEC, it is just a matter of time before Johnson has this [triple-option] team contending for championships.
http://collegefootball.rivals.com/content.asp?CID=831054
For another good post on the triple-option, locoguano made a good post above:
Click to expand...