is the lsu defense the standard to rate sec qb's?

Discussion in 'The Tiger's Den' started by snorton938, Mar 8, 2004.

  1. DeafValleyBatnR

    DeafValleyBatnR Founding Member


    Are you sure this is right I thought that SD took Leaf first and then Peyton.

    As a matter of fact I am sure Leaf was # 1 maybe I am wrong but I don't think so.
     
  2. LSUDeek

    LSUDeek All That She Wants...

    Here's a shot:

    Roethlisberger.

    No cheating!
     
  3. MikeD

    MikeD Sports Genius

  4. Eleven

    Eleven Founding Member

    Leaf was the overall #1 and SD chose Leaf.

    a few years later SD traded Vick away. did they trade Vick and then get LT? if so....good freakin choice.
     
  5. lsu99

    lsu99 whashappenin

    Didn't Mel Kiper Jr. make a big production of how the Colts screwed up by taking Manning over Leaf?
     
  6. tirk

    tirk im the lyrical jessie james

    Manning was picked #1.


    Chargers passed on Vick for Tomlinson. not a bad pick in itself.

    now will they snag another bust @ QB this time around....
     
  7. captainpodnuh

    captainpodnuh Baseball at da Box

    OK. I thought it was Leaf who was taken first, but that was proven incorrect. All that aside, I still think Ben R is the pick of the litter.
     
  8. Eleven

    Eleven Founding Member

  9. tirk

    tirk im the lyrical jessie james

    arguable actually on Vick although the avg NFL viewer is so much into vick-sanity that they wouldnt consider it. biggest thing is RBs dont last long and before a team could build around LT his career may be over. on the other hand, vick could be there for the next15 yrs bringing championships. you always go for the superstar qb as a rule....and thats why nor can i argue. thats why fitz or mw wont be chosen over manning. Id take ben over these guys for that reason.
     
  10. Eleven

    Eleven Founding Member

    i agree totally tirk.

    but the thing is....

    they've been in the league the same amount of time. how many games has LT sat out compared to Vick?

    generally QBs do outlast RBs, but how much diffrent is Vick from a RB?

    i think Vick is one of the most talented players to ever play in the NFL, but what good is that when he's on the bench all the time?

    im looking at it from a GM standpoint. i would have taken LT and then tried to get a good pocket passer.
     

Share This Page