First Team QB Rohan Davey RB Joseph Addai RB Jacob Hester WR Josh Reed WR Dwayne Bowe TE Robert Royal OT Andrew Whitworth OG House Johnson C Ben Wilkerson OG Rudy Niswanger OT Ciron Black DE Marcus Spears DE Marquise Hill DT Glenn Dorsey DT Kyle Williams LB Bradie James LB Trev Faulk LB Ali Highsmith CB Patrick Peterson CB Corey Webster/Chevis Jackson S Craig Steltz S LaRon Landry KR Skyler Green PR Domanick Davis K Colt David P Donnie Jones Coach: Les Miles Second Team QB JaMarcus Russell RB Charles Scott RB LaBrandon Toefield WR Michael Clayton WR Early Doucet TE Richard Dickson OL Nate Livings OL Will Arnold OL Brett Helms OL Stephen Peterman OL Brian Johnson DE Jarvis Green DT Chad Lavalais DT Claude Wroten DE Melvin Oliver LB Lionel Turner LB Darry Beckwith LB Jeremy Lawrence CB Chevis Jackson CB Jonathan Zenon FS Ryan Clark SS Jessie Daniels KR Trindon Holliday PR Chad Jones K John Corbello P Chris Jackson Coach: Nick Saban
Addai really only started one year and he was injured in that year too. I would put Hester and Scott because they are the only ones who really played for more than one year. It's a testament to our team talent that we have such a struggle between which RB's are better. Great problem to have. I would put Russell or Davey as well. Flynn only played one year and wasn't all that spectacular although he was what we needed at QB. How bout DC? Muschamp or Pelini?
Addai was a maniac catching passes out of the backfield, he single handedly won us two separate Florida games (04,05) and was easily the most talented RB to play at the school in the 00s. I'm a big Charles Scott fan, but to counter your argument, Scott only started 23 games at LSU. Addai started 19 and played in 8 more games (51 to 43). Addai is 5th all time among LSU running backs in rushing and receiving yards.
That's true. But what I meant was, Addai's only real year as the go-to-guy was in 2005 and that was because Broussard was injured. Addai has contributed a lot over the years as a runner and receiver and it's definitely a close call. Scott showed heart to me in 08 being the only bright spot on the offense and still managing to get 1000+ yards.
2nd team, for "Schlitz and Giggles" QB JaMarcus Russell RB Charles Scott RB LaBrandon Toefield WR Michael Clayton WR Early Doucet TE Richard Dickson OL Nate Livings OL Will Arnold OL Brett Helms OL Stephen Peterman OL Brian Johnson DE Jarvis Green DT Chad Lavalais DT Claude Wroten DE Melvin Oliver LB Lionel Turner LB Darry Beckwith LB Jeremy Lawrence CB Chevis Jackson CB Jonathan Zenon FS Ryan Clark SS Jessie Daniels KR Trindon Holliday PR Chad Jones K John Corbello P Chris Jackson Coach: Nick Saban
Too many good Tigers will be left out. Please go back and make the roster a 2 deep this time. :geaux:
That would be a pretty tough position for me to decide on, as well. Davey, Mauck, Russell, Flynn. All could make an argument.
I second the motion about coach Saban. Glad someone pointed that out. (don't fall off your chairs :lol
