What is your philosophical argument? If a God is out there then he obviously created you. It isn't necessary to have that knowledge. In fact, it is impossible. A priori knowledge of creation is impossible. All you have is what you think it is all about regardless if you are right or wrong.
Logical fallacy. False Cause -- presuming that a real or perceived relationship between things means that one is the cause of the other. If God is out there, then multiple Gods could be out there. Another God may have created you. Or perhaps God isn't into creation at all and allows nature to proceed.
I think you meant to reply to me? Anyway. The point is not if God is out there. It could be any creator(s) or it could be nothing. It doesn't matter and you don't have to believe in it to exist and it doesn't have to have you believe in it for you to exist either. The question posed, "Why did God make Hawking an atheist?" does nothing to challenge anyone. If you don't believe in God, it is an invalid question. If you believe in God, it is a simply that he created you and it is up to you to believe in him. The Devil is there to lead you astray and that was my simple answer. I have already stated my beliefs previously but it is ok to be the Devil's advocate.
That was not my objection. The notion that if God exists he must have created us is illogical. There is neither correlation nor causation. There are no invalid questions.
