Is this proposal a good idea or is it just pandering by Clinton and McCain. Most experts agree that it isnt good for the economy from most of what I have read. However, Clinton has a twist to her idea of having the oil companies pay for the loss of revenue? Is her plan still a bad idea or a good pandering idea? Or just a good idea? I really dont think its a good idea, just because the savings are about 30 dollars, which probably would be more for me since I drive alot. However, if it does happen will the oil companies just increase the price around the same amount of the tax?