Who would rather have playing QB on LSU Jefferson or Andrew Luck? | Page 9 | TigerFan.com

Fang · Nov 20, 2011

TigerTap said: ↑

You forgot Bama. Andrew Luck plays for himself first, not his team. LSU
looked at him...he's just not the type to buy into a "team first" mentality & likely would have transferred.

Look where he ended up. Do you believe he was more interested in winning championships or his NFL Draft status?
Click to expand...

That's what I'm F'n talking about! Cheers

Fang · Nov 20, 2011

TigerTap said: ↑

Not criticizing him, he's just a very different type of player. The school he chose was the perfect vehicle to showcase his talent.
Click to expand...

If you want to win a NC u play in the SEC mf'r

KingEmeritus · Nov 20, 2011

TigerTap said: ↑

Not criticizing him, he's just a very different type of player. The school he chose was the perfect vehicle to showcase his talent.
Click to expand...

You said he plays for himself and not for his team. That sounds like criticism to me. Also, in what world is Stanford the perfect place to showcase his talents? Luck has absolutely no talent around him. He could have gone to many other schools and put up far greater numbers.

Fang · Nov 20, 2011

TigerTap said: ↑

Stanford affords him the luxury of being the Main player there. Is there anyone talking about Stanfrd RBs or DTs? No, it's all Andrew Luck. Kid out of Texas, figures he can lght up most the hapless DBs in the notoriously defenselesss & pass happy PAC 10.

He did. I don't see that as insulting.
Click to expand...

Jefferson not luck best option for LSU.

Mjolnir · Nov 21, 2011

Rwilliams said: ↑

If lsu had luck as their qb they wouldn't have to rely on a running qb and wouldn't be forced to pass only eight times in a game as they did aginst ole piss.

Luck would be a fit in any offense. He would make randal a heisman contender at receiver. We would throw the ball 25 times a game because luck can make NFL style throws. Luck can throw his receiver open, read a defense and check out of a play just as mett did with the bootleg saturday.

If you think luck wouldn't start at lsu because jj is the better qb or running threat you are mistaken. You don't risk getting your qb hurt running the ball 20 times a game if you have the caliber qb that luck is. You don't see NFL qb's running 20 times a game except for a very few instances.

For anyone to say jj is a better fit for lsu than luck would be is not looking at why we run an offense that relies on the qb to run the ball. Luck at qb for lsu would change how this offense is structured. Any coach would build his offense around a smart qb that can make throws that are in many cases indefensable.

There are a few coaches on this board.They are infinately more qualified than I am. I listen closely to what they say. Not one of them would start jj or jl over luck if all three were on his team from day one as a freshman and all being in the same class together from day one. Luck would have been the qb for lsu for the last three years.

The reason why we have a running qb is because we don't have an Andrew Luck on this team with the experience to start. Next year we will have a qb with the skills as luck playing qb. We won't need to play an offense that relies on the qb to run the ball. We will have an entirely diffrent approach at offense next year. You won't see the running qb scheme next year. You will see a heisman caliber qb playing a pro style offense and the days of lsu relying on speed option and spread option offensive game plans will be a thing of the past. Jj isn't in the same class of skills as luck. You will see on draft day who is the multi millionare and who is damn glad they graduated with a degree.
Click to expand...

Nothing to disagree with. Good post.

I like USC's QB as well as Wisconsin's, too.

tigerchick46 · Nov 21, 2011

mctiger said: ↑

Les just ordered Mett to kneel four times and kill this thread.
Click to expand...

Hilarious! Just spit my coffee

LSUTiga · Nov 21, 2011

tigerchick46 said: ↑

Hilarious! Just spit my coffee
Click to expand...

You need to start swallowing.

Cajinkid · Nov 21, 2011

Luck . I would take Luck over any QB in the country ....and some in the NFL .

Guido Merkins · Nov 21, 2011

With Luck, LSU beats Bama by 2 TDs.

red55 · Nov 21, 2011

Fang said: ↑

I never said one thing that was race related. Only pigs act like pigs.
Click to expand...

"I feel sorry for Jefferson bc fans like you don't realize how he gets the brothers pumped up." --Fang

Nobody is fooled by your BS.